A Conservation Plan with Something for Everyone

December 23rd, 2011

by Michael Carr

When the opportunity arose in 2007 to purchase and protect the former Finch, Pruyn & Co. lands, we knew we had to act. At 161,000 acres, the magnitude of this forest and fresh water conservation effort is significant. In addition to providing essential habitat for wildlife and featuring 16,000 acres of wetlands, 300 lakes and ponds, 90 mountain peaks, and 415 miles of rivers and streams, these lands touch people’s lives and livelihoods.

In consultation with a variety of interest groups and community leaders, The Nature Conservancy’s local Adirondack Chapter and New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) have agreed to conserve and protect these lands, and the critical economic benefits they provide to local communities, as follows:

·      92,000 acres will continue to be working forests with sustainable logging;
·      65,000 acres will be transferred to the state to become part of the Forest Preserve; and
·      1,100 acres will be set aside for community purposes in three towns.

The plan does more than represent our collective commitment to clean air, clean water and healthy forests for current and future generations. It meets the needs of loggers, business owners, wildlife, and the tens of thousands of local residents and millions of visitors who use Adirondack forests for recreation.

The lands touch six counties and 27 towns in the Adirondacks, with more than 80% of the property in these five towns: North Hudson, Minerva, Newcomb, Indian Lake and Long Lake. All of the towns have already approved the state’s anticipated expenditures from the Environmental Protection Fund (EPF) toward related land and conservation easement purchases. The EPF is a dedicated fund, replenished each year with money generated through an existing real estate transfer tax, for environmental programs, ranging from open space and farmland protection, to zoos and botanical gardens, to recycling programs and waterfront redevelopment programs.

More than half of the land will continue to be available for sustainable timber harvest operations. Some of it will become part of the Forest Preserve, thereby unlocking recreation and business opportunities associated with the tourism industry—an industry recognized as a vital growth sector of the upstate economy by the North Country Regional Economic Development Council. Indeed, protecting these Adirondack forests and their vast water resources adds immeasurable value to the region as a major travel and recreation destination. Ten million people visit the Adirondacks annually, supporting one out of every five jobs in the area, and visitors spend more than $1 billion at local inns, restaurants, convenience stores and outdoor outfitters.

All of the property to be transferred to the state has been closed to the public for more than a century, but will become open and available in the coming years to everyone for hunting, hiking, fishing and other recreational uses, and some new snowmobile trails will be created. Included are some of the most scenic places in the Adirondacks, such OK Slip Falls, in Indian Lake; Essex Chain of Lakes, in Minerva and Newcomb; Thousand Acre Swamp, in Edinburg; wild upper reaches of our state’s longest river, the Hudson, and key tributaries like the Cedar and Indian Rivers, in multiple towns; and Boreas Ponds, at the southern edge of the High Peaks Wilderness, in North Hudson. For the first time ever, these places will soon be accessible to you, your friends and neighbors, and everyone who finds inspiration in natural places.

The project also adds value to the timber industry. As of December 2010, the 92,000 acres of commercial timberlands, now owned by a company who bought the land as a socially responsible investment, have been protected by a land preservation agreement with the state called a conservation easement. The easement keeps the land in sustainable forestry, allows for continued recreational leasing, and secures some public access to places identified as important to local communities, including snowmobile connector trails already open for use in nearly a dozen towns. The rural town of Newcomb is already experiencing economic benefits from new snowmobile trails. Timber harvested from the easement lands continues to supply green certified pulpwood to the Finch Paper mill in Glens Falls, which employs approximately 750 workers.

We anticipate key properties to transfer to NYSDEC in the coming years. In the meantime most of the land will continue to be leased for exclusive use by about two dozen private hunt clubs. Though hunt clubs will have to relocate to privately owned forests, the plan allows for a 10-year transition, ensures members will still have these lands to hunt on, and expands recreational opportunities for local residents and visitors currently shut out of the forest.

This balanced approach to conserving the former Finch lands is an investment in people as much as it is an investment in nature. We are bolstering the economy while also protecting clean air, clean water, and wildlife habitat.

For more information about this project, including video links, press releases and news clips, visit www.nature.org/heartofadirondacks.


***

Michael Carr is executive director of the Adirondack Chapter of Nature Conservancy

4 Responses to “A Conservation Plan with Something for Everyone”

  1. Peter Heckman Says:
    This "Conservation Plan with Something for Everyone" is a fatally flawed plan, and a fee purchase would be a grave mistake. There is no ecological nor economic logic; stewardship would decrease, and economic adversity would increase. No one, other than a handful of investors, stands to gain a thing. It's bad for the environment, bad for the regional economy, and is destructive to the social fabric of the Adirondacks. It is morally reprehensible. If Governor Cuomo does nor direct DEC to change this plan to an easement purchase, it will be political suicide for him. What a waste...
  2. Fred Monroe Says:
    Adirondack local governments were aware that Governor Spitzer had circumvented the local government veto of the use of Environmental Protection Fund money to purchase International Paper Company lands, by the use of donated money and governor's discretionary funds, when they negotiated with DEC and the Nature Conservancy on the Finch lands. Local governments acquiesced and negotiated the best deal they could with the knowledge that their vetoes could be circumvented. More recently Adirondack-wide organizations and local governments have opposed the fee purchase of 65,000 acres as "forever wild" forest preserve because it will cause the loss of forest industry jobs, the loss of economic benefits to communities of 20 recreational leases, and the destruction of 200 hundred hunting and fishing cabins. The following have passed resolutions opposing the fee purchase of the former Finch land: Adirondack Association of Towns and Villages Adirondack Park Local Government Review Board Adirondack Regional Chamber of Commerce Franklin County Lewis County Warren County Hamilton County Town of Plattsburgh Town of Stony Creek Town of Chester Town of Clifton Town of Long Lake Town of Minerva Town of Broadalbin Town of Tupper Lake Town of Saranac The residents of those local governments, and the members of the regional bodies, understand the negative economic consequences of adding another 65,000 acres of "forever wild lands to the current 2.7 million acres. They also know that the alternative of conservation easements would prevent development of the 65,000 acres without locking up needed fiber supply, destroying primary forestry jobs, the 7 to 1 secondary jobs supported by the forestry jobs, the jobs related to the recreational leases, and without the destruction of 200 cabins.
  3. Donald MacElroy Says:
    Mr. Carr fails to disclose that three of the 5 Towns that he claims support the fee acquisition of the Finch lands: Indian Lake, Long Lake and Minerva, have all passed Town Board resolutions this year opposing the fee purchase and calling for the State to acquire conservation easements instead in order to protect the jobs and economic activity generated by private ownership. A fourth, Newcomb, has passed a resolution requesting that the State preserve the recreational clubs in their present homes.
  4. Patrick Mannix Says:
    Mr Carr has also omitted that The Adirondack Regional Chamber of commerce has STRONGLY opposed fee purchase, but does support an easement. He fails to recognize that the wildlife on the private sector land is far better than the forever wild land. The ponds, lakes and lands of the hunting and fishing clubs have more loons, eagles, osprey, otter ect... due to their exceptional stewarship.If the TNC truely wants to PRESERVE these lands, than a co-operative easement purchase is the only way to go. Everone wins!!

Leave a Reply

Please help us stop spam by using this form! Then click on "Submit Comment".